Bahama Mama Recipe Pitcher. Blend the dark rum, coconut rum, lime juice, pineapple juice, and ice in a blender until a slushy texture forms. The bahama mama, what started out as a classic rum punch to give any party a tropical flare has.

This recipe is by the glass, though, for sipping on the patio. 1 quart chilled orange juice 1 quart chilled pineapple juice 1/4 cup grenadine 2 cups chilled coconut rum, or to taste. Take an instant vacation with a sip of this bahama mama.